No other paper towel brand came close to the weight Bounty was able to hold which was an average of 2, grams or about 4. The brand that came in second was Brawny which was only able to hold an average of 1, The results of this experiment somewhat shocked me by how strong each paper towel.
I thought they would be weaker than they actually performed. In order to make my experiment better in the future, I could try using different types of liquids or use a different way to hold the paper towel. I wanted to test out which leading paper towel brand was actually the best.
From experience, I think that Bounty brand paper towels will be the strongest. Bounty claims their paper towels are the strongest, so I thought it was time to put it to test. The way I wanted to test the strength was by adding pennies in the center of the paper towel until the paper towel tore.
I tested each paper towel 5 times each and found an average. I laid one of the paper towels on top of a food container and tapped it down. Then I poured 2 ounces of water in the center of the paper towel and began adding pennies one by one. Wal-Mart Store Brand, on the other hand, broke fairly easily as shown on the data table.
After the paper towel tore, I removed the paper towel and poured the pennies into a drain bowl to drain any leftover water, dried the bowl and then taped another paper towel on and repeated for each test. The average amount of pennies it could hold was pennies 2, grams. That is nothing compared to Bounty. Brawny and Sparkle were relatively close and stayed in the middle with the averages of pennies or 1, Bounty actually surprised me being as strong as it showed. Could you make do with the studious use of clean white towels?
But one toppled bottle of wine or leaking meat package can take out a slew of little white linens. To clean those white towels, you then have to use your washer, often in its own cycle, wasting water and energy.
And using and reusing a dishrag is, according to food savant Alton Brown, a bacterial bacchanal. Finding an expert opinion on paper towels is not easy. Professional kitchens have clean white towels and laundry services. Cleaning services, daycare providers, and kennels tend to buy thin recycled towels on bulk contracts. Some people depend on them for just about every cleaning task, while others save them for kitchen work. Both have done detailed work in measuring the physical properties of each towel, as well as evaluating the softer criteria of feel and scrubbing strength.
I also found a few bloggers with smart takes and opinions on paper towels, and one in particular, Len Penzo , who took it on himself to do his own rigorous tests, which were far more documented and explanatory than anything else we found online. Penzo found that Bounty and Viva were the best performers of the seven brands he tested, but he gave Bounty third place and Viva fourth place behind the more budget-oriented Costco-brand and Scott towels he tried, because his criteria were more heavily weighted toward value a natural position for someone who primarily blogs about personal finance.
A good paper towel picks up the most liquid or semiliquid mess with the fewest sheets. But absorbency is not king, despite what blue-liquid advertising fantasies have emphasized. In our tests, we wanted to determine what the exact delta in performance was between absorbency and toughness for the most current formulations of Bounty and Viva.
After all, our theory would go out the window if either Bounty or Viva was significantly tougher or more absorbent than the other. For scrubbing strength, I wrapped each paper towel in a uniform way around a new scrubbing sponge. I soaked the side with the scrubbing surface with a close approximation of 15 milliliters and then ran it back and forth across the textured strip of a wooden coffee table , examining the towel after every back-and-forth for any tears of 1 mm or greater, which would presumably lead to greater tears.
I chose my unique coffee table after discovering that polished granite and wood did almost nothing to the towels at hand. I tested the contenders five times each. To test absorbency per a given amount of area, I cut each towel to the same size and weighed them dry with the American Weigh Signature Pocket Scale , which resolves to. I tested five sheets each of Bounty and Viva, and of two eco-friendly alternatives.
A strong paper towel should come from a good, sustainable source of wood fiber. As with toilet paper, buying the most environmentally friendly product and having to use more of it is still wasteful, especially when you factor in packaging and return trips to buy more.
At first, I was hopeful that we could find an even more environmentally friendly towel that was made of recycled materials. Manufacturers could stand to use fewer resources to make paper towels, and it would be similarly good for users to be able to recycle them more often.
I spoke with Gary M. Scott, PhD, professor and chair of the Department of Paper and Bioprocess Engineering at the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry , about the nature of making paper towels using recycled materials and sustainable-fiber sourcing. Paper towels made with recycled materials are inherently inferior because they use preprocessed pulp, which makes for a weaker product.
But not all is lost on the environmental front. Generally, Scott told us, major buyers such as Bounty buy wood harvested on cycles as long as 60 years and refuse to buy from unverified sources. If you know you want an ecologically friendly pick, see our favorite recycled paper towel below. Bounty Select-A-Size is just Bounty, but with more tear-off points that many people find convenient for reducing unnecessary use.
And Bounty is quite good at what it does, as we and other testers see it. In general use, I found that Bounty had that most unique kind of home-goods appeal: It picked up liquid, it was strong in most of the applications I needed it for, it felt good in my hand, it left no noticeable lint, and it was easy to find at any store that carried paper towels.
So Bounty Select-A-Size did really well, even with less absorbency and fewer square feet per roll 41 square feet on each roll; most range between 38 and 65 feet. At the time, CR had this to say about Bounty paper towels in its laboratory tests: That third version, the low-cost Bounty Basic, was still better than half of the total paper towels tested.
Good Housekeeping has some words, too. Standard Bounty scored just one notch below Viva. Personal finance blogger Len Penzo took his own review of paper towels very seriously and given the extent of his testing, so did we.
He measured milliliters of absorbed liquid in beakers and wrapped towels around a sponge, scrubbing them back and forth across a laminated countertop. He did each of these tests three times for each of the seven major brands he tested, using uniform towel sizes. As a personal finance blogger, he also focused on the cost per roll and per sheet in his rankings. In our tests Bounty was the best at scrubbing compared with Viva, and sometimes much better.
On average, it could take These towels feel less like paper and more like ShamWow. If absorbency is the key in your job or your home—you clean up a lot of pet leavings, perhaps—or you need a particularly soft paper towel to occasionally stand in for face towels or tissues, you might go with Viva. It is a notably soft and absorbent option that is still decent at scrubbing.
Eisenberg found that Viva picked up the most orange soda every single time. Reusable cloths are arguably more useful than an environmentally friendly paper towel, but this is your best bet.
Other reviewers found it viable, too, especially if you value cleaning strength over raw absorbency. Consumer Reports rated Marcal as Very Good in scrubbing and wet strength in Good Housekeeping pretty much echoes what I found in my tests:
I was able to conclude that my hypothesis was correct. After testing all of my products, Bounty was the strongest paper towel. No other paper towel brand came close to the weight Bounty was able to hold which was an average of 2, grams or about pounds.
VIVA paper towel looks really soft and thin, and bounty looks like is stronger. But VIVA is the strongest one. When we put the coin and the water on top of the Bounty paper towel, it easily teared apart, and when we did it to viva it didn't.
Hypothesis for which brand of paper towels is strongest. Which paper towel brand is the strongest bounty brawny or viva? I need help on my science fair project . Performing the Paper Towel Experiment Hypothesis “More expensive brands of paper towel are more absorbent.” What You Will Need for the Paper Towel Experiment. At least four brands of absorbent paper towel; A stopwatch; A beaker; A graduated cylinder; A funnel; Method. Fill the beaker up with exactly ml of water; Take a sheet of the first brand of towel.
For instance, if one brand of paper towel advertises itself as the strongest, your hypothesis could read, "Brand X is the strongest wet paper towel." Create a backboard that has some examples of the paper towels, pictures from the experiment, and the most important parts of the report, like hypothesis, conclusion, and important data, such as the number of quarters each brand handled. Nov 29, · I need help writing a Hypothesis for my science project help? My experiment question is Which band of paper towel is the strongest. The 3 brands of paper towels i Status: Open.